• team@colbyfinancialreview.com

The Psychology Behind Financial Decisions

  • Noah Carpenter
  • May 27, 2026

Share on:

Why do some lottery winners go broke while average earners quietly become extremely wealthy? Contrary to popular belief, financial success is not entirely determined by intellect, high income, or the ability to “beat the market.” It is also heavily influenced by psychology, emotions, experiences, and one’s overall savings habits. As Morgan Housel, author of The Psychology of Money, explains, financial success often comes from emotional control, long-term thinking, and personal habits.

At first glance, it seems obvious that someone making $200,000 a year would be better off than someone making $75,000 a year, but that is not always the case. We will refer to the person making $200,000 as person one, and the person making $75,000 as person two. Person two is clearly more limited in the lifestyle they can afford than person one. Perhaps person one can afford a relatively small house and one vacation a year, while person two can afford a larger house and multiple vacations. Psychologically, person two recognizes these limitations and wants to grow their wealth to a level where they can eventually afford person one’s lifestyle. Instead of taking yearly vacations, they invest that money, and instead of owning a large house, they settle for a modest apartment. Person one, however, may not feel the same pressure to save because they can already live comfortably and spend freely. In this example, person two actually ends up with a higher savings rate than person one. This “savings rate,” as Morgan Housel describes it, is the gap between your income and your ego.

People also tend to underestimate the role that luck and personal experience play in financial decision-making. Someone who grew up during a recession or watched their parents struggle with debt may become far more cautious with money than someone raised in financial stability. Likewise, investors who experience major market crashes early in their lives often carry those emotional memories into future decisions, becoming either overly fearful or overly aggressive. Housel argues that every person views money through the lens of their own experiences, which explains why two intelligent people can make completely different financial decisions while both believing they are being rational. Financial behavior is rarely driven purely by numbers on a spreadsheet; it is shaped by emotions, memories, risk tolerance, and personal history.

As someone’s income rises, their lifestyle often increases along with it. To build wealth, your lifestyle cannot grow at the same rate as your income. Keeping that gap wide between income and spending increases the savings rate. However, this is much harder than it sounds. Modern culture revolves around instant gratification and the display of wealth. As people move up the social and financial ladder, the pressure to spend increases: nicer clothes, luxury cars, expensive vacations, and second homes all become status symbols.

Browse By Topics

Business

[category_post_count cat_id="12"] Posts

Macro

[category_post_count cat_id="11"] Posts

Research

[category_post_count cat_id="13"] Posts

Pick of The Week

[category_post_count cat_id="14"] Posts

Sign up with your email address to receive the newest articles in your inbox.

Market Snapshot

[ccpw id="3957"]

Related Posts

Expected Trends, Unexpected Outcomes

Introduction Rather than suggest a pick for this week, we thought it’d be better to take a step back and look at how the market has been moving over the past few months. Since the CFR team left campus in mid-May, a lot has happened in the equities market, some of it expected and some […]

Record Revenues, Temporary Gains: The Economics of the 2026 World Cup

The 2026 World Cup is generating record short-term revenue for U.S. businesses, but its overall impact on the broader economy is likely to be temporary rather than transformational.

Stock Pick of the Week (6/29)

Vertiv (VRT) is this week’s stock pick of the week.

Strong Numbers, Stretched Households

Strong income and spending masked growing financial strain as households saved less and struggled to keep pace with inflation.